Surrogacy Law Reform Rejected: Why Parentage, Citizenship and DNA Evidence Matter More Than Ever
As reported in the Times[1] on 8th September 2026, the Government has rejected calls to automatically recognise intended parents as the legal parents of children born through surrogacy from birth, thus maintaining the current legal framework that requires a Parental Order after a child is born.
This decision follows a parliamentary debate which was triggered by a petition that attracted more than 113,000 signatures and has renewed discussion about parental rights, child welfare, immigration law and the role of DNA testing in establishing family relationships.
For solicitors, immigration practitioners and families involved in surrogacy arrangements, particularly international surrogacy, the debate highlights a growing legal challenge: proving parentage across multiple jurisdictions.
What Has the Government Decided?
Under current UK law, intended parents are not automatically recognised as the legal parents of a child born through surrogacy. Instead, they must apply to the Family Court for a Parental Order, normally in the period between six weeks and six months after birth. Until that order is granted, the surrogate remains the child’s legal mother and has parental responsibility.
Campaigners have argued that this process is expensive, time-consuming and emotionally stressful for families who may already have spent years and substantial sums pursuing the surrogacy arrangement. Supporters of the proposed reform wanted the intended parents to be recognised as legal parents immediately upon birth of the child.
However, ministers rejected the proposal, stating that the current framework contains important safeguards designed to protect both children and surrogate mothers. The Government confirmed that it has no immediate plans to introduce legislation changing this legal position.
Why Are MPs Reluctant to Change the Law?
Many MPs who were involved in the debate argued that the existing Parental Order process already serves a vital purpose.
The six-week post-birth waiting period allows a surrogate mother time to consider her position after childbirth and ensures that any consent provided is fully informed and free from pressure. Several MPs described the period as an essential safeguard rather than an unnecessary delay.
The Government’s position is that any future reform must continue to protect:
- The welfare of the child
- The rights of surrogate mothers
- The interests of intended parents
- Public confidence in surrogacy arrangements
Ministers also highlighted the increasing complexity of international surrogacy arrangements, where differing legal systems can create significant challenges in determining who is recognized as a parent in different countries.
International Surrogacy Is Increasing
Statistics discussed during the parliamentary debate show how rapidly surrogacy has grown in recent years.
Parental Order applications increased from 117 in 2011 to 537 in 2025. Campaign groups have also reported that a significant proportion of these cases involve international surrogacy arrangements.
Many UK parents now enter surrogacy arrangements abroad in countries where the legal framework differs substantially from that of the United Kingdom.
This creates complex questions around:
- Citizenship
- Nationality
- Immigration status
- Passport applications
- Legal parenthood
- Recognition of foreign birth certificates
- Inheritance rights
In many cases, solicitors must navigate not only UK family law but also immigration law and the legislation of the country where the child was born.
Where DNA Testing Becomes Important
One of the less discussed aspects of international surrogacy is the role of DNA evidence.
While DNA testing does not determine legal parenthood under UK law, it can provide highly persuasive scientific evidence that helps establish biological relationships.
A legal DNA test may be used to demonstrate:
- A biological father-child relationship
- A biological mother-child relationship
- Relationships between siblings
- Grandparent-grandchild relationships
For families involved in international surrogacy arrangements, such evidence can become particularly important when applying for immigration permission, citizenship or a passport.
DNA Testing and Immigration Applications
The Home Office does not generally require DNA testing as a mandatory part of an immigration application. However, DNA evidence may be submitted voluntarily where it helps prove a claimed family relationship.
This can be particularly useful when:
- Birth documentation is incomplete
- Foreign records are unavailable
- Parentage is questioned
- A child has been born through an overseas surrogacy arrangement
- Citizenship depends upon proof of a biological relationship
In such cases, DNA testing can provide strong supporting evidence alongside legal documents and witness statements.
Importantly, any DNA testing intended for official purposes should be performed by an Ministry of Justice approved provider such as ourselves at dadcheckgold[2]. In particular, we have extensive experience in surrogacy matters and would be pleased to help with any questions.
British Citizenship and Surrogacy
Nationality issues frequently arise in surrogacy cases.
A child born overseas through surrogacy will not automatically qualify for British citizenship in every case. The outcome depends on numerous factors, including:
- The nationality of the intended parents
- Whether a biological connection exists
- The country of birth
- The legal status of the parents under applicable laws
- Whether a Parental Order has been granted
Because citizenship law can be complex, families should seek specialist immigration advice as early as possible.
In some circumstances, DNA evidence may assist in establishing the biological relationship upon which a nationality claim is based.
What Solicitors Should Be Advising Clients
With international surrogacy continuing to grow in popularity, practitioners should consider parentage issues well before a child is born since:
- The law in the country where the surrogacy arrangement takes place may be significantly different from UK law.
- Questions surrounding citizenship and immigration status should ideally be addressed before travel arrangements are made.
- Where biological parentage may be relevant, accredited DNA testing can provide valuable supporting evidence.
- Despite ongoing calls for reform, intended parents must still comply with the existing UK legal framework.
Looking Ahead
The Government’s decision means that intended parents will continue to rely on the Parental Order process for the foreseeable future. While campaigners have pledged to continue seeking reform, ministers have made clear that any changes will need to prioritise child welfare and the protection of surrogate mothers.
For legal professionals, the debate reflects a much wider trend. Family structures are becoming increasingly international, and questions of parentage now regularly intersect with immigration, nationality and identity.
As these cases continue to rise, DNA testing is likely to play an increasingly important role in helping families establish biological relationships and support legal applications across multiple jurisdictions.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can DNA testing prove legal parenthood?
No. DNA testing can establish a biological relationship but does not determine legal parenthood. Legal parenthood is determined by the relevant law and court orders.
Can the Home Office request DNA evidence?
Yes. In certain circumstances, DNA evidence may be requested or voluntarily submitted to help establish a claimed family relationship.
Is DNA testing mandatory for immigration applications?
No. However, it can provide powerful supporting evidence where documentary proof is limited or disputed.
Can DNA testing assist with citizenship applications?
Potentially, yes. Where citizenship depends on proving a biological relationship with a British citizen parent, DNA evidence may assist.
What type of DNA test is required for legal purposes?
A legal DNA test should be performed by an accredited laboratory with strict identity verification and chain-of-custody procedures.
Our related Services
- Immigration DNA Testing
- British Citizenship DNA Testing
- Paternity Testing
- Maternity Testing
- Sibling DNA Testing
- Grandparent DNA Testing
- Family Reconstruction DNA Testing
If you would like to discuss DNA testing for immigration, nationality or family law matters, please call us on 0191 543 6334 and we would be pleased to help.
[1]Surrogate parents will not be recognised from birth, ministers rule
[2] https://dadcheckgold.com/
Share this: